Paper Tiger Review: Miles Teller and Adam Driver Are Brothers in Way Too Deep in Another Excellent, Devastating James Gray Family Drama

Paper Tiger (2026)
Paper Tiger (2026)
Cinephile CornerBest New Movie

James Gray is one of modern America’s most consistent filmmakers, in terms of both quality and the kinds of stories he chooses to tell. Over more than 30 years and nine features, he has never made even an average movie, and he keeps digging deeper into family dynamics pushed to their very limits and breaking points. Paper Tiger, which premiered in competition at Cannes back in May before NEON brought it to theaters this month, is no exception. If anything, it might be the best case yet for just how good he is.

Gray sticks to what he does well and what he knows best. He’s a Queens kid, so it should be no surprise to see him return to his stomping grounds for the second film in a row (following the equally excellent Armageddon Time in 2022). And it shouldn’t be a surprise to see him working in the historical context of a pair of brothers falling into an entanglement with the mafia, either. But like he’s done time and time again with Little Odessa, The Yards, and We Own the Night, Gray puts so much polish on these spiraling circumstances that you once again feel in good hands, with a filmmaker comfortable commanding every inch of the frame and every frame of this 115-minute family tragedy.

It helps that Gray can enlist a trio like Miles Teller, Adam Driver, and Scarlett Johansson. It helps even more when all three give some of the best performances of their respective careers.

Teller and Driver play Irwin and Gary Pearl, brothers who’ve always been close and looked out for one another. Gary is a former NYPD officer whose ties run high up the political ladder across the boroughs, and things have mostly worked out for him. All except a difficult divorce with ballooning costs that’s put a real burden on his affluent lifestyle. So when he sees a chance to make a quick buck consulting for Russian immigrant businesses down at the docks that are struggling to comply with environmental regulations, he takes it. He knows exactly the kind of people he’s dealing with. He just doesn’t tell Irwin, even as he brings his little brother in on the plan for his engineering expertise. Ignorance is bliss, as far as Gary’s concerned.

Irwin isn’t necessarily clueless, but it’s a plan hatched by his big brother, so he has no reason not to trust it. So much so that after an initial meeting with a prospective client goes well, he brings his two boys down to the docks late at night for a little show-and-tell. His timing couldn’t be worse. He stumbles right into the Russian mafia’s preparations for some illegal dumping, and knowing exactly who Irwin is and who his brother is, the mob gets spooked. What follows is a game of cat and mouse between the Pearls and the mafia, who tell the brothers to pay up for Irwin’s lack of “street smarts,” as Gary puts it, while Gary tries to temper nerves during this volatile time.

There’s a real big brother, little brother dynamic between Gary and Irwin, and Driver and Teller infuse it into every little element of their characters. Teller is excellent as the somewhat blinded idealist who thinks this can and should be brushed under the rug so his family can go back to living a normal life. It’s nice to see him doing grade-A acting again after a string of movies like The Gorge, Eternity, and Michael, and pairing up with an auteur outside of Joseph Kosinski for once.

Driver, meanwhile, plays an older brother who believes, probably in large part because of his old badge, that things will eventually break his way, even as every sign points toward the opposite. He finally gets material that matches his classical, towering leading-man charisma. I was one of the few who liked Megalopolis (and I still think Ferrari is better than it got credit for), but Driver has always been tipped as one of the great actors in Hollywood, someone who works with real filmmakers yet always seems to be elevating material that struggles to click with critics and mainstream audiences alike. Not here. This one clicks.

And then there’s Johansson, reuniting with Driver for the first time since Marriage Story, though this time she’s married to his brother. She plays Irwin’s wife Linda, who’s going through a hell of a lot on her own but can’t bring herself to speak up because of the escalating paranoia her husband is already exhibiting. Without diving into spoilers, the film drops a devastating revelation on her late in the second act, right as everything else is spiraling out of control, and the look on her face when she receives the news is so believable and heart-wrenching that it nearly flattens a family already pushed to its very, very limits. Johansson is a powerhouse in essentially every scene she’s in. It’s clearly one of the best supporting performances of the year, and easily one of my favorite performances of her career.

The movie culminates in one of Gray’s signature, impeccably shot shootouts, this time between Gary and members of the Russian mafia in a patch of tall grass. Nobody shoots a shootout quite like James Gray does (anyone who’s seen the car chase in the rain in We Own the Night knows what I mean), and it’s as tense and precise as anything he’s ever put to screen.

It’s a devastating movie about the actualities of American life. The dream isn’t quite a façade, but it’s a dog-eat-dog world, and a few wrong decisions, oblivious or not, can send you down a path you never would’ve expected. Before you know it, people who were once in your life just aren’t anymore. Gray makes dramas that cut deep and stick with you, and Paper Tiger, simple in its narrative structure but complex in the depths of its characters, stands out even in a filmography of undeniably rich movies.

READ MORE MOVIE REVIEW: The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, Pressure, Possible Love

Like many of the greats before him, Gray’s consistency almost works against him. How do you make a movie that stands out in a catalogue full of near-perfect films? At the very least, it is another notch in the belt, and one of the best movies of 2026.

Score: 9/10

Paper Tiger movie poster

Movie Details

Paper Tiger (2026)

Released
Runtime
1 hr 55 min · 115 minutes
Rated
R
Director
James Gray

Follow Cinephile Corner on Letterboxd

Scroll to Top