Madden Review: Nicolas Cage’s John Madden Biopic Feels Like It Is Four Hours Long

Madden (2026)
Madden (2026)

I am 26 years old. I have virtually no connection to John Madden as a figure within the football world. I know him almost exclusively as the namesake of the EA Sports video game franchise, plus a faint, word-of-mouth understanding of him as a TV color guy from all the sports talk radio I listen to in the morning. That’s about it.

But everyone who knew him or worked with him revered him. Madden was a titan in a sport that rapidly rose in popularity through the late 20th century, and his personality as a kind-hearted football junkie left a mark long after he stepped away from the sideline. It’ll surely stay with us for years following his passing in 2021.

Which is what makes Madden such a puzzling project from the jump. Amazon MGM hands a biopic about one of the most beloved figures in football history to David O. Russell, then casts Nicolas Cage as the man himself, and I’m still not entirely sure what they were trying to achieve. Casting Cage suggests the tone they were going for right away: playful and tongue-in-cheek, as outrageous and boisterous as Madden’s personality was. And the ensemble around him hints at more of the same. Kathryn Hahn plays his wife Virginia, Shane Gillis plays his next-door neighbor, John Mulaney plays EA Sports mastermind Trip Hawkins, and Christian Bale plays Raiders owner Al Davis.

Bale plays it about as straight as anyone in the film, and even he, behind all the glitz, glamour, and occasional ruthlessness of Al Davis, seems to be in on the joke, despite this being another one of his “transformations.” For what it’s worth, Cage is doing a bit of transforming into Madden himself, even if his vocal performance is, as Cage himself put it, not an exact one-for-one match. Nicolas Cage is no Frank Caliendo.

So then why, if the movie is trying to commemorate Madden’s legacy through a raucous football comedy, is Madden simultaneously not very funny, and so preoccupied with everyone around John Madden being frustrated by him? His wife thinks he’s a manchild. Al Davis treats him like Trump treats JD Vance. His broadcasting partners think he’s a dope. For a film that exists to celebrate the guy, it really doesn’t have much nice to say about him in real time.

And maybe he really was just a guy who loved football and drawing up plays, and that was that. But if that’s the case, there’s no meat on the bone for a feature-length film, let alone one that pushes two hours. Cage never materializes enough inner warmth for his Madden to resonate. Will Ferrell was in early talks to play the role back in 2023, and I’d imagine his take would have carried the film along a bit nicer. Warmth underneath the bluster is basically Ferrell’s whole brand.

My biggest issue, though, is the structure. Madden is split nearly right down the middle into two movies. The first half covers the final days of his coaching career, but it zips past any attempt to build the world or explain how he became a Super Bowl-contending coach in the first place, opting instead for highlight reels that land on the Raiders’ Super Bowl win over the Vikings. (Even with the Vikings sitting at 7-2 right now, I can’t escape the endless Vikings disappointment purgatory.) Then it jumps straight into his post-coaching years. The movie never finds one specific element of his life particularly interesting, so it plays all the basic notes of his Wikipedia page in straight succession.

READ MORE MOVIE REVIEWS: Tony, Resident Evil, Disclosure Day

I’ve never been much of a David O. Russell guy, but his last two films have been remarkably atrocious. Between this and Amsterdam, he’s a long way from the limelight he held during his run from The Fighter to American Hustle. Ditto for Bale, whose last five films are now Madden, The Bride!, The Pale Blue Eye, Amsterdam, and Thor: Love and Thunder. That’s not what the people want!

Madden just isn’t very good, and it was probably doomed the moment the cast was announced. Everybody here could be doing much better.

Score: 3/10

Madden movie poster

Movie Details

Madden (2026)

Released
Runtime
1 hr 52 min · 112 minutes
Rated
R

Follow Cinephile Corner on Letterboxd

Scroll to Top