There are four or five moments in Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie where my brain basically short-circuited, not because the movie is confusing, but because it feels borderline impossible that it exists at this scale with this kind of scrappy, “how did they pull that off?” energy. Matt Johnson and Jay McCarrol have always had a particular talent for turning cringe into momentum and turning momentum into a full-on set piece. Here, they do it on a bigger canvas without sanding down what made Nirvanna the Band the Show special in the first place.
If you’ve never seen the web series Nirvana the Band the Show or the later TV continuation of the same name, the premise still lands quickly because it’s so perfectly dumb and so perfectly specific. Matt and Jay, playing fictionalized versions of themselves, are a two-man band in Toronto with one eternal dream: book a gig at the Rivoli. The funniest detail is also the most revealing one: they are still chasing this “career” despite barely behaving like a band at all. The movie treats that obsession like it’s a sacred quest, which is exactly why it works.
Structurally, it’s a mockumentary that keeps shapeshifting into a time travel adventure. The initial catalyst, a publicity stunt involving the CN Tower and the Toronto Blue Jays’ SkyDome, is the kind of idea that sounds like a joke you’d say out loud and immediately regret. Johnson and McCarrol commit to it with such sincerity and such technical follow-through that the stunt becomes the first “I can’t believe they filmed this” moment of several. From there, the movie uses a Back to the Future riff as a springboard into a story that becomes bigger, faster, and more deranged without ever losing the petty, beautiful core of it: Matt and Jay are addicted to the chase, addicted to the bit, and addicted to each other’s specific brand of chaos.
A huge part of why the movie plays as “bigger” than it should is how it’s made. Jared Raab’s camera work keeps things urgent and on-the-fly, like the movie is being assembled while it’s happening, but the construction underneath it is way more meticulous than it first appears. It’s the kind of filmmaking that makes you watch a scene and simultaneously laugh at the stupidity of the plan and admire the competence required to stage it. That blend is rare, and it’s the secret sauce of why Matt Johnson works both as a filmmaker and as a screen presence.
Comedy-wise, it’s not just reference humor or “look who showed up” cameos, even though the movie has fun with its pop-culture temperature and the fact that it’s built out of a very specific Toronto identity. It’s character comedy rooted in escalation. One small lie becomes a bigger lie. One plan to impress the Rivoli becomes five plans stacked on top of each other. One attempt to manufacture legacy becomes a panic spiral where these two individuals find themselves in predicaments seemingly impossible to get out of. The movie understands the specific misery of being an adult still chasing the exact dream you had in your early twenties, especially when that dream is less about art and more about validation.
And that’s where the movie surprised me the most. For all the “how did they get permission to do that?” insanity, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie is also weirdly sincere about friendship. It’s a story about two guys who have built their entire identities around a shared mission, and who then have to sit with what happens when that mission gets distorted. The time travel framework turns into a way of literalizing the thing we all do anyway: replaying old versions of ourselves, wishing we could change a conversation, wishing we could rewrite one decision that sent everything slightly off-course. The movie just does it with a camcorder and a death wish.
It also carries that rare “aspiring filmmaker inspiration” vibe without ever becoming self-important. BlackBerry showed that Johnson could scale up and still keep his voice sharp, but this feels like the purest extension of what he does best: take an absurd objective, treat it like life or death, and then build a movie out of the collateral damage.
The movie is basically engineered to keep topping itself, and sometimes you can feel it straining to go even bigger when it already has the audience in its pocket, or hitting the breaks after a massive sequence. It’s also the kind of comedy where your tolerance for Matt and Jay as people will dictate your tolerance for the whole experience. If their particular brand of frantic, socially awkward sabotage doesn’t hit for you, two hours of it will feel like a lot.
READ MORE MOVIE REVIEWS: The Love That Remains, Sirāt, Good Luck, Have Fun, Don’t Die
But when it hits, it really hits. The set pieces are nuts. The pacing is aggressive. The craft is impressive. And by the time it gets to its most heartfelt ideas, it earns them, which is the hardest trick to pull off in a movie this committed to being a live-wire spectacle. It makes sense that it played like a crowd-pleaser in festival settings, because it’s built to create that “did you see that?” high.
Score: 8/10
Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie (2026)
- Cast: Matt Johnson, Jay McCarrol
- Director: Matt Johnson
- Genre: Adventure, Comedy, Science Fiction
- Runtime: 102 minutes
- Rated: R
- Release Date: February 20, 2026
- Movies Like Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie: Friendship, Everybody Wants Some!!, Saturday Night, More Movies Like Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie
- Follow us on Letterboxd
