Review: Star Trek: Generations is an occasionally interesting and slightly uneven cinematic voyage. The movie introduces us to a promising new crew while offering a brief farewell to an old legend. William Shatner and Patrick Stewart star in this transition film.
Star Trek: Generations Review
Beaming down onto the bridge of Star Trek: Generations (1994) feels like stepping into a parallel universe. Captain Picard (Patrick Stewart) and the Enterprise-D crew navigate a familiar cosmos, yet the shadows of the legendary Kirk (William Shatner) and his Enterprise-B loom large. Director David Carson deftly orchestrates this temporal story, but the film ultimately becomes a fascinating case study in balancing legacy with new beginnings.
Patrick Stewart, with his Shakespearean gravitas, is a worthy heir to the starship captain’s chair. He pilots the Enterprise-D with a quiet confidence that contrasts beautifully with Shatner’s bombastic Kirk. The supporting cast, from the ever-logical Data (Brent Spiner) to the similarly ever-charming Riker (Jonathan Frakes), provides a comforting continuity in characterization alongside a welcome influx of fresh faces. However, there’s a noticeable void compared to the vibrant ensemble of the Enterprise-B, where familiar heroes like Scotty and Chekov offer nostalgic winks to Trek‘s golden age.
And starting with the elephant in the room, Generations takes a bold gamble with Kirk’s demise. It’s a gut punch, a gamble that left most fans grieving and few others cheering the passing of the torch. As a newcomer to the Star Trek universe, I found it to be quite similar to how franchises are rebooted in our current day, a way to clear the decks and embrace the “Next Generation” without the weight of history. Yet, for longtime superfans, it must have felt like a warp core breach to their hearts.
But the ultimate demise of the film lies in its story, and here’s where Generations stumbles off course. Soran, our resident villain, feels like a recycled Romulan probe – menacing, sure, but lacking the depth and complexity of a Khan or a Q. Malcolm McDowell throws everything he has at the role, but the character remains flat. The plot itself, while serviceable, treads familiar ground – a rogue scientist, a ticking clock, a last-ditch mission to save the day. It’s Trek comfort food, but without the spices of true innovation that make the best films in this series pop.
But Generations occasionally finds the right pocket and shines in its moments of time-bending brilliance. The way the film weaves past and present together, culminating in a mind-bending climax, is a strong example of David Carson’s vision. The final showdown, though predictable, delivers the requisite phaser-firing thrills. Ultimately, Generations feels like a middling entry in the franchise, a steppingstone for the “Next Generation” crew. I just hope that the subsequent films manage to find their own lane a bit more.
Star Trek: Generations is an occasionally interesting and slightly uneven, cinematic voyage. It introduces us to a promising new crew while offering a brief farewell to an old legend. While the plot lacks the foundation and quirks of some previous entries, the film’s temporal acrobatics and moments of lively set design and physicality still stand out.
Score: 5/10
Genre: Action, Adventure, Science Fiction
Watch Star Trek: Generations on Max and VOD
Star Trek: Generations Cast and Credits
Cast
Patrick Stewart as Captain Jean-Luc Picard
Jonathan Frakes as Commander William T. Riker
Brent Spiner as Data
LeVar Burton as Geordi La Forge
Michael Dorn as Commander Worf
Gates McFadden as Beverly Crusher
Marina Sirtis as Deanna Troi
William Shatner as James T. Kirk
Malcolm McDowell as Soran
Crew
Director: David Carson
Writers: Ronald D. Moore, Brannon Braga, Rick Berman
Cinematography: John A. Alonzo
Editor: Peter E. Berger
Composer: Dennis McCarthy
