Crossing Delancey is the kind of romantic comedy that remembers what adulthood feels like. Joan Micklin Silver builds a world so specific that it becomes universal, a New York where bookstores, delis, and family kitchens carry as much weight as flirtations. The movie sits alongside the late eighties high points, close to Moonstruck and When Harry Met Sally…, yet it leans a little more serious and a little more tender.
Amy Irving plays Izzy, a bookshop clerk caught between two versions of a future. There is Anton Maes, a visiting author played by Jeroen Krabbé with just enough sleaze to feel dangerous and alluring. He fits the idea of who Izzy thinks she should be with, the literary life that flatters her tastes. Then there is Sam, a neighborhood pickle seller played by Peter Riegert, who is direct without being pushy and attentive without begging. He is not the fantasy, he is the person who listens.
Silver’s New York is fully lived in and deeply Jewish, drawn from community spaces that feel observed rather than invented. You can sense the history in the buildings and the gossip in the air. That texture grounds the movie’s small conflicts, and it lets Izzy’s choices matter without ever turning the story into a lecture. You get the jokes, the awkwardness, and the little kindnesses that accumulate into love.
Irving is wonderful. She makes Izzy smart, vain, funny, and self aware, sometimes all in the same scene. Riegert is even better than I remembered. His confidence during the arranged introduction orchestrated by Izzy’s mother is curious and appealing, and his patience when Izzy tries to set him up with her friend Marilyn, played by Suzzy Roche, becomes one of the film’s most uncomfortable and revealing sequences. Krabbé plays Anton as a man who loves adoration more than he loves people, which clarifies the choice that Izzy will eventually face.
The movie’s influence is easy to feel in later New York stories. It has the hometown showiness and prickly humor that directors like Noah Baumbach gravitate toward, and I could not help thinking of Mr. Jealousy while watching. Silver’s touch is warmer, though. She lets characters speak with their habits and their work, and she frames romance as something that grows in the spaces between obligations.
What lingers is how adult it all feels. Crossing Delancey is situationally funny and sharp about single life in your thirties, but it never turns its characters into punchlines. It respects desire and embarrassment in equal measure. By the end, the film has earned its sweetness, and the city around Izzy and Sam feels like it is rooting for them too.
READ MORE MOVIE REVIEWS: Raising Arizona, Blue Velvet, Heathers
Not remembered as loudly as the era’s biggest hits, Crossing Delancey is every bit as thoughtful and maybe a touch more humane. It is a perfect autumn watch, full of crisp air and warm rooms, and it belongs in the conversation with the best romantic comedies of its time.
Score: 9/10
Crossing Delancey (1988)
- Cast: Amy Irving, Peter Riegert, Reizl Bozyk, Jeroen Krabbé, Sylvia Miles, George Martin, John Bedford Lloyd, Claudia Silver, David Hyde Pierce, Rosemary Harris, Suzzy Roche
- Director: Joan Micklin Silver
- Genre: Comedy, Romance
- Runtime: 97 minutes
- Rated: PG
- Release Date: September 16, 1988
- Movies Like Crossing Delancey: Materialists, You Hurt My Feelings, Splitsville, More Movies Like Crossing Delancey
- Follow us on Letterboxd
