A Haunting in Venice (2023) Movie Review and Film Summary

Review: A Haunting in Venice fails to break free from the constraints of mediocrity that have dogged the Christie franchise. Kenneth Branagh’s film, like his prior entries in the series, struggles to deliver the tension and intrigue that should be inherent in the genre.

A Haunting in Venice movie (2023) — A Haunting in Venice

In Kenneth Branagh’s latest addition to the ever-expanding Agatha Christie cinematic universe, A Haunting in Venice, one might be forgiven for feeling a profound sense of déjà vu. Branagh, who has been at the helm of the recent Christie adaptations, has built a reputation for attracting star-studded ensembles, only for the final product to fall frustratingly short of its potential. This is, unfortunately, par for the course in the realm of Agatha Christie, and A Haunting in Venice hardly veers from that well-trodden path. While the film carries a darker, more ominous undertone, the sum of its star-studded cast and the shadowy allure of Halloween proves insufficient to elevate it above the trappings of mediocrity.

For those who have followed Kenneth Branagh‘s recent attempts at the beloved Christie novels, the overarching sentiment is often one of disappointment. These films tend to lack the juice and energy you might expect from stories so deeply embedded in the history of classic mystery literature. While they may lure audiences with their array of A-list actors, they too often fall short in delivering the depth and entertainment value one would hope for. A Haunting in Venice adheres to this same pattern, making it a remarkably unremarkable installment in the ongoing franchise.

The narrative of A Haunting in Venice unfolds against the backdrop of Halloween, half-heartedly setting a tone that is decidedly darker and gloomier than its predecessors. This change in setting and atmosphere brings a semblance of novelty to the well-trodden formula, yet it doesn’t quite succeed in breathing new life into the franchise.

Once again, the film boasts an eclectic cast, a recurring strength in the Branagh-Christie collaborations. While it may not be the most star-studded ensemble in the series, with a discernibly thin roster, it still manages to feature some noteworthy talent. Michelle Yeoh, an actress of undeniable screen presence, takes center stage and emerges as a standout performer. Her presence alone adds a touch of gravitas and credibility to the film. Tina Fey and Kelly Reilly also deliver commendable performances, infusing the story with their own unique charisma and delivery.

However, where A Haunting in Venice ultimately stumbles is in its inability to build tension and intrigue to captivate its audience. Christie’s stories are known for their intricate puzzles and enigmatic characters, but this film, like its predecessors, appears to overlook these crucial elements. The plot feels more like an obligatory vehicle for its impressive ensemble rather than a captivating mystery. It is this lack of genuine tension and intrigue that leaves the viewer wanting more, longing for the kind of loose and goofy charm that can make Christie adaptations so engaging when done right.

Branagh’s own take on Hercule Poirot has always been a divisive one. While his meticulous and eccentric portrayal has its merits, it sometimes teeters on the brink of self-indulgence. However, the character himself, much like the film, often lacks the playfulness and wit that one might associate with Christie’s famous Belgian detective. It’s that elusive element of fun that has contributed to the success of films like Knives Out, and it’s one that seems to continuously elude Branagh’s franchise.

It’s worth noting that Death on the Nile, the previous entry in this devolving franchise, was, by some accounts, the most enjoyable of the lot. Yet even it failed to leave a lasting impression or offer anything truly unique to the genre. This recurring mediocrity is becoming a glaring issue for the franchise, particularly in a cinematic landscape where films like the aforementioned Knives Out have successfully reinvigorated the murder mystery genre.

While Branagh’s adaptations offer an occasionally visually appealing journey back in time, complete with lavish period details and sumptuous cinematography, they often falter when it comes to substance. A Haunting in Venice is no exception. It may offer fleeting moments of dark ambiance, but it lacks the memorable characters, clever twists, and genuine engagement that are the hallmark of truly compelling mysteries.

The Agatha Christie cinematic universe has, perhaps inadvertently, paved the way for more innovative and daring entries in the genre. Films like Knives Out have clearly demonstrated that it is possible to breathe new life into the classic murder mystery formula. Yet, the Christie adaptations have become increasingly overshadowed by their own shortcomings, with each entry driving home the feeling that they are a far cry from the excitement and originality that has come to define contemporary whodunit filmmaking.

A Haunting in Venice fails to break free from the constraints of mediocrity that have dogged the Christie franchise. The film, like its predecessors, struggles to deliver the tension and intrigue that should be inherent in the genre. While it boasts a remarkable cast and an atmospheric Halloween setting, these elements alone are not enough to mask the underlying issues that have long plagued the series. The haunting, in this case, is not of the supernatural variety, but rather the lingering feeling of missed opportunities and unfulfilled potential that continues to haunt these Agatha Christie adaptations.

Rating: 4/10

Genre: Crime, Horror, Mystery, Thriller

Watch A Haunting in Venice (2023) on Hulu and VOD

Join our newsletter